
With Nazi Germany on its last legs, Muhammad and his brother were digging for fertilizer in the reddish-brown soil near the Egyptian village of Nag Hammadi in the winter of 1945 when they struck something solid beneath the cliffs of Jabal al-Tarif. Clearing away the dirt, they uncovered an earthenware jar, wedged between the rocks and standing roughly twice the height of a microwave oven. Muhammad did what any rational person would do and carefully struck the clay with his mattock, making sure he wasn’t freeing an imprisoned jinn, the Arabs’ version of a demon.
Confident it was safe, Muhammad brought the books home and threw them onto the straw piled beside his mother’s clay oven, and she lit her daily fires with some of the sixteen-hundred-year-old papyri over the next few weeks. Eventually, what was left of the books ended up on the black market, sold for cents on the dollar or even sometimes in exchange for cigarettes.
Scholars would discover far too late that those buried 5th centurt books were the losing side of a long war over what Christianity was, a war whose victors had spent more than a millennium convincing the world that their version had been the only one from the very beginning.
Where the First Seventy Years Left Off
A Galilean preacher who’d told other fellow Jews that God’s kingdom would arrive within a generation was crucified by Rome about the year 30, and his disciples dispersed. Paul, a missionary who never met Jesus, provides the earliest account of what made them change their views, although his list of witnesses to the risen Jesus makes no mention of an empty tomb.
The movement remained within Judaism for roughly 20 years after Jesus’ execution, until Paul prevailed in the debate over the admission of non-Jews who hadn’t undergone circumcision. Rome’s persecution following the fire of 64 and the destruction of the Temple in 70 put an end to the Jerusalem leadership that had personally known Jesus. By the year 100, the majority of the believers were non-Jews with their own writings and a growing estrangement from the synagogue. The gospels that followed each described Jesus as more divine and more physical than the previous one.
This left a religion with a core figure and no consensus regarding him. No one had decided who had the right to make such decisions, what Jesus was in regard to God, or whose texts qualified as scripture.
Today we’ll focus on Christianity between the years 100 and 500. Readers who want the full account of those first seventy years can find it in this piece: How Christianity Was Made: The Origins.
A Church With No Agreed Answers
If you had hopped on H. G. Wells’ time machine to visit Christian congregations around the year 150, you would’ve found people in every city who claimed Jesus and disagreed about nearly everything else. You’d have witnessed some who taught that Jesus was an ordinary man God had adopted at his baptism, and others who taught that he’d only seemed to have a body, since a divine being couldn’t suffer. Marcion, a wealthy shipowner from the Black Sea coast who’d arrived in Rome around 140, taught that the angry God of the Hebrew Bible was a lesser power and that Jesus came from a different and kinder one. A gospel used by Jewish believers had Jesus call the Holy Spirit his mother, and Origen, the most productive Christian scholar of the third century, quoted the line and tried to make sense of it. The Hebrew word for spirit is feminine, so the saying probably sounded natural to its first readers.
Bear in mind, each of these people thought they were as Christian as it gets.
Four Gospels Because the World Has Four Winds
Around 140, Marcion published the first known list of Christian scriptures, containing a trimmed version of Luke and ten letters of Paul, with the entire Hebrew Bible thrown out, and the churches that opposed him then had to say which books they did accept. Little did he know that this move would change the course of Christianity, but all for the wrong reasons, from Marcion’s perspective, that is.
Around 180 Irenaeus, bishop of Lyon in what’s now France, answered with five volumes against rival teachers and a case for exactly four gospels. His reason for the number was that the world has four corners and four winds, so the church needed four pillars.
Irenaeus also supplied the test that shaped everything afterward. A teaching counted as true if it could be traced through an unbroken line of bishops back to the apostles, which handed the authority to decide to the bishops themselves. Their opponents’ books survived mostly as quotations inside the bishops’ attacks, so most of what the world knew about the losing side for the next seventeen hundred years came from the people who beat it, until a farmer digging in Egypt in 1945 turned up a sealed jar holding thirteen books of texts that bishops had condemned.
Persecution That Sorted Christians Into Camps
For most of the second century and the first half of the third, persecution came in local flare-ups, when a governor, a mob, or a bad harvest called for someone to blame. In 250 an emperor ordered every resident of the empire to sacrifice to the traditional gods and collect a certificate proving it, and many Christians complied, bribed an official, or bought a certificate they hadn’t earned. The Great Persecution that began in 303 went further, with churches torn down, scriptures seized and burned, and bishops who handed over their copies to avoid arrest branded as traitors by the ones who refused.
That charge split North Africa for generations, one side wouldn’t accept baptisms or ordinations performed by a bishop who’d handed over the books, while the other said the sacraments worked no matter who performed them, which meant the church was already arguing about who held authority before an emperor ever offered to settle it.
The Emperor Who Called the Dispute Trivial
Constantine took the western half of the empire in 312 after crediting the Christian God with his victory in a battle outside Rome, and by 324 he ruled all of it. He gave the churches money, land, and tax exemptions for clergy, and then discovered that the church he’d favored couldn’t agree with itself. In Alexandria a priest named Arius was teaching that the Son was created by the Father and so had a beginning, which meant a time existed when the Son wasn’t. His bishop, Alexander, taught that the Son had always existed beside the Father, and the quarrel spread through the eastern churches in sermons, letters, and songs. Constantine wrote to both men calling the question trivial and telling them to drop it, and when that failed he called the bishops to Nicaea.
A Word From Outside the Bible
Around three hundred bishops came, nearly all from the eastern half, and the creed they approved said the Son was of one substance with the Father. The Greek word behind that phrase isn’t in the Bible, and one bishop who attended wrote that Constantine proposed it himself. All but two bishops signed, and those two went into exile alongside Arius.
The council settled less than most churchgoers assume. It said almost nothing about the Holy Spirit, and no record shows anyone raising the question of which books belonged in the Bible. The doctrine of the Trinity (one God in three persons) took another fifty-six years and a second council, at Constantinople in 381, to finish.
Five Exiles and One Deathbed Baptism
Constantine himself didn’t treat Nicaea as final. Within a decade he’d recalled Arius from exile and sent Athanasius, the bishop of Alexandria who led the Nicene side, into exile instead. When Constantine died in 337 he was baptized on his deathbed by a bishop who’d backed Arius. His son Constantius II ruled the eastern half for most of the next quarter century and favored bishops who rejected Nicaea’s wording, and Athanasius was exiled five times under four different emperors.
The people history calls Arians were a loose crowd of bishops with several different views, most of whom objected to one word in one creed and had little interest in Arius himself. Their opponents attached his name to all of them. The side that won in the end did it with imperial help, when the emperor Theodosius declared in 380 that his subjects should follow the faith of the bishops of Rome and Alexandria and called everyone who didn’t “demented and insane.” A council at Constantinople the next year wrote the creed that most churches still recite.
The Letter That Listed Twenty-Seven Books
Around the year 325 Eusebius, a bishop and historian, sorted the books then in circulation into accepted, disputed, and rejected, and Revelation appeared on more than one of his lists. In 367 Athanasius sent his yearly Easter letter to the churches of Egypt with a list of the twenty-seven books that make up today’s New Testament, and it’s the earliest surviving list that matches. Regional councils in North Africa endorsed the same list in 393 and 397, and no council or vote ever covered the whole church.
The list never became universal, though. Churches in Syria used a shorter one for centuries, leaving out several of the shorter letters and Revelation, and churches in Ethiopia kept a longer one that they still use today. The books in the jar from 1945 were copied in the fourth century and buried near a monastery, and some historians link the burial to a letter like Athanasius’, though nobody can prove it.
Ephesus, Chalcedon, and the Churches That Walked Out
Settling what Jesus was in relation to God opened the next question, which was how a single person could be both divine and human. A council at Ephesus in 431 condemned Nestorius, the bishop of Constantinople who objected to calling Mary the mother of God, and the church in the Persian empire went its own way afterward. The council at Chalcedon in 451 declared that Christ had two natures in one person, and the churches of Egypt, Syria, and Armenia refused to accept it. Those churches still exist and still count themselves the continuation of the early church.
By the year 500 the church that had claimed to be one body existed as at least three, the one backed by the empire, the one in Egypt, Syria, and Armenia, and the one in Persia, all out of communion with each other.
If there’s enough interest, the next piece will cover the thousand years in which the church lost Jerusalem, Antioch, and Alexandria to a new faith, crowned emperors in the West, sent armies east to take the holy places back, and ended up sacking the capital of its own eastern half. Along the way a forged document handed the popes a claim to rule much of the western empire, and it wasn’t conclusively exposed until the 1400s.
If you enjoyed this piece and want the series to continue, let me know by liking it or leaving a comment.
The Unholy Truth is a full-time commitment, made possible directly by readers like you. If you find value in these deep dives, consider upgrading your subscription to keep the work going and unlock all exclusive content on the site.
Sources and Further Reading
Bart D. Ehrman, Lost Christianities: The Battles for Scripture and the Faiths We Never Knew (Oxford University Press, 2003)
Bart D. Ehrman, How Jesus Became God (HarperOne, 2014)
Walter Bauer, Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity (Fortress, 1971)
Bruce M. Metzger, The Canon of the New Testament: Its Origin, Development, and Significance (Oxford University Press, 1987)
Harry Y. Gamble, The New Testament Canon: Its Making and Meaning (Fortress, 1985)
R.P.C. Hanson, The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God: The Arian Controversy 318-381 (T&T Clark, 1988)
Rowan Williams, Arius: Heresy and Tradition, rev. ed. (Eerdmans, 2002)
Timothy D. Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius (Harvard University Press, 1981)
Elaine Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels (Random House, 1979)
Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.11.8; Athanasius, Festal Letter 39 (367); Theodosian Code 16.1.2; Socrates Scholasticus, Ecclesiastical History 1.9 and 1.37-38



Interested in the next chapter. I don't know much about what happened between Augustine and the Reformation.
It all gets quite messy, and after some 2,000+ years of endless persecutions, deaths, and wars in the name of Christianity (as well as other faiths) it's discouraging how little humanity has learned. WanderingBackroads, I was raised in the Church of Christ, so I'm familiar with the things you are saying. I began asking lots of questions, and was even asked to transfer out of my Sunday School class because my teacher told me he couldn't deal with my questions. I was 12-13 years old. So...If you read my latest posting, 'A Universal Truth' https://substack.com/home/post/p-225219210, you'll see how my path seriously changed. I became more interested in the common threads that run through humanity in terms of how to be a decent human being.