It all gets quite messy, and after some 2,000+ years of endless persecutions, deaths, and wars in the name of Christianity (as well as other faiths) it's discouraging how little humanity has learned. WanderingBackroads, I was raised in the Church of Christ, so I'm familiar with the things you are saying. I began asking lots of questions, and was even asked to transfer out of my Sunday School class because my teacher told me he couldn't deal with my questions. I was 12-13 years old. So...If you read my latest posting, 'A Universal Truth' https://substack.com/home/post/p-225219210, you'll see how my path seriously changed. I became more interested in the common threads that run through humanity in terms of how to be a decent human being.
These pieces are so helpful. Thank you for sharing and making sense of this mess. I attended a Church of Christ assembly for many years, and that denomination claims to practice first century Christianity, thus the book of Acts became their gold standard for behavior and doctrine, aside from members having all things in common. As I read Acts, what stands out is how present and powerful the Holy Spirit was in giving witness to and validating the message. But that quickly changed, as if that Spirit was withdrawn after Paul and the true apostles died. And it could not save any of them from horrible deaths. So what happened? Or are the miracles stories like surviving a poisonous snake bite and jail breaking by angels jus fabrications to convince the reader Paul was who he claimed to be?
Around three hundred bishops came, nearly all from the eastern half, and the creed they approved said the Son was of one substance with the Father. The Greek word behind that phrase isn’t in the Bible, and one bishop who attended wrote that Constantine proposed it himself.
As I wrote a few weeks back on your site ὁμοούσιον τῷ Πατρί was around long before Nicea and Constantine. Saying it is not in the bible is a side track because it is a conclusion drawn from the bible.
The dating of New Testament materials is uncertain, but it seems to stretch over a period of decades. I suspect Greek changed over that period so whether a word appeared a few times in some texts is a lot like someone drawing a straight line through a single point, there's got to be more evidence. (And it may be that new words appeared because people were addressing new issues and needed a new vocabulary.)
Interested in the next chapter. I don't know much about what happened between Augustine and the Reformation.
It all gets quite messy, and after some 2,000+ years of endless persecutions, deaths, and wars in the name of Christianity (as well as other faiths) it's discouraging how little humanity has learned. WanderingBackroads, I was raised in the Church of Christ, so I'm familiar with the things you are saying. I began asking lots of questions, and was even asked to transfer out of my Sunday School class because my teacher told me he couldn't deal with my questions. I was 12-13 years old. So...If you read my latest posting, 'A Universal Truth' https://substack.com/home/post/p-225219210, you'll see how my path seriously changed. I became more interested in the common threads that run through humanity in terms of how to be a decent human being.
These pieces are so helpful. Thank you for sharing and making sense of this mess. I attended a Church of Christ assembly for many years, and that denomination claims to practice first century Christianity, thus the book of Acts became their gold standard for behavior and doctrine, aside from members having all things in common. As I read Acts, what stands out is how present and powerful the Holy Spirit was in giving witness to and validating the message. But that quickly changed, as if that Spirit was withdrawn after Paul and the true apostles died. And it could not save any of them from horrible deaths. So what happened? Or are the miracles stories like surviving a poisonous snake bite and jail breaking by angels jus fabrications to convince the reader Paul was who he claimed to be?
Keep up the good work!
Please continue
Around three hundred bishops came, nearly all from the eastern half, and the creed they approved said the Son was of one substance with the Father. The Greek word behind that phrase isn’t in the Bible, and one bishop who attended wrote that Constantine proposed it himself.
As I wrote a few weeks back on your site ὁμοούσιον τῷ Πατρί was around long before Nicea and Constantine. Saying it is not in the bible is a side track because it is a conclusion drawn from the bible.
The dating of New Testament materials is uncertain, but it seems to stretch over a period of decades. I suspect Greek changed over that period so whether a word appeared a few times in some texts is a lot like someone drawing a straight line through a single point, there's got to be more evidence. (And it may be that new words appeared because people were addressing new issues and needed a new vocabulary.)
And wasn't there an Old Testament verse that linked the Massiah to the Holy Spirit?
Not sure?