Given the current rise in anti-Semitism, I'd like to push back on your explanation of why the genocide of Jews has more salience than that of Russians or others. You suggest it was that Jews were "Western," while "Western" civilization had long considered Jews other. The relevant point is that Jews were killed simply because they were Jews, while most war deaths, even of civilians, serve to further war ends.
Hi Mitch, this is a bit sensitive subject. I would first give you a lengthy answer but it would sound like I am trying to downplay what happened to European Jews.
What I meant to say is that Russia was the enemy after World War 2, and how many Russians died during the war is not even the footnotes when we talk about the war today. They weren't among the people the allied powers mourned for. This is expected, not critism. But shows our biased nature when we look at history.
That's fair, though in my opinion Jews were also considered an enemy by many people throughout the West, a situation that went underground for a generation or two following the Holocaust but that has now re-emerged. Anything that takes away from realizing the unique survivability of anti-Semitism is, I think, ill advised, though I understand your point about our ignorance of the sheer numbers of Soviets killed by Nazi Germany.
If we agree that antisemitism in Germany was caused, not in small extent, by the Jewish elites being rich and influential at the background of poor society, then nowadays we have a picture that bears some resemblance: the Jewish elites in the US colluding with the genocidal government politicians in Israel, at the background of huge wealth disparity in the US society and real genocide happening to Palestinians. Trump's ideas of building his hotels in the Palestinian territory after what remains of Palestinians is forced away certainly does not help, as he is colluding with the genocidal politicians.
Those Jews and Israelites do behave quite like those of the past in Germany, and then worse (in Germany Jews were not responsible of any genocide).
I understand that this is certainly not the only source of the current rise of antisemitism, and that for antisemites in the Western countries this is what they observe from away and not live through themselves.
Still, I suspect this is probably an important factor, even if not the only one.
Thanks for sharing your opinion. However, I want to clarify something.
When I refer to German Jewish elites who became the public face of the revolutionary movement, I’m not claiming they made a mistake, nor that they led the revolution that ended in disaster. I’m describing how many ordinary Germans perceived the situation at the time, including the belief that Jews were rich and largely unaffected by the economic collapse—a belief Hitler stresses in his book Mein Kampf. From my perspective, it isn’t relevant whether influential revolutionaries were Catholic, Protestant, or Jewish. Every individual represents themselves, not the demographic they belong to, even when someone believes they recognize a pattern. Correlation isn’t causation. One thing is safe to say: they were all Germans who wanted a better Germany, but were guided by little sensible strategy.
Hitler didn’t invent that ideology about German Jews. He stepped into beliefs that had been sold to him at some point as a young man, and he resold them more effectively than anyone else at the time. He wasn’t the author of those ideas—his tactics simply made him an exceptionally skilled reseller of the spirit of his time, tactics that might not have worked a decade earlier or later.
In other words, my point is about perception: how large segments of ordinary German society interpreted events when Hitler arrived on the scene. That perception is historically documented.
Combined with centuries-old Christian antisemitism—reinforced by figures like Martin Luther, who campaigned for violence against Jews—it created a perfect storm that had been building long before Hitler exploited it.
I have no idea to what extent Jews were "elites" in pre-Nazi German society. What seems obvious to me is that when a society is failing to satisfy the needs of the large majority, the natural category to attack would be wealthy and powerful people, not some minority that is associated in people's perception with wealthy and powerful people. It also seems obvious to me that Jews have been attacked for being both "too rich" and "too poor" -- Cossacks hardly attacked peasant villages due to the Jews' excessive wealth. So I suspect that wealthy and powerful people divert a common-sense reaction from those who feel excluded to an alternate target, and anti-Semitism has always provided one. And, watching the reaction to the Jewish state's response to 1,200 murders and hundreds of kidnappings, I see the same anti-Semitism in the reaction.
Given the current rise in anti-Semitism, I'd like to push back on your explanation of why the genocide of Jews has more salience than that of Russians or others. You suggest it was that Jews were "Western," while "Western" civilization had long considered Jews other. The relevant point is that Jews were killed simply because they were Jews, while most war deaths, even of civilians, serve to further war ends.
Hi Mitch, this is a bit sensitive subject. I would first give you a lengthy answer but it would sound like I am trying to downplay what happened to European Jews.
What I meant to say is that Russia was the enemy after World War 2, and how many Russians died during the war is not even the footnotes when we talk about the war today. They weren't among the people the allied powers mourned for. This is expected, not critism. But shows our biased nature when we look at history.
That's fair, though in my opinion Jews were also considered an enemy by many people throughout the West, a situation that went underground for a generation or two following the Holocaust but that has now re-emerged. Anything that takes away from realizing the unique survivability of anti-Semitism is, I think, ill advised, though I understand your point about our ignorance of the sheer numbers of Soviets killed by Nazi Germany.
If we agree that antisemitism in Germany was caused, not in small extent, by the Jewish elites being rich and influential at the background of poor society, then nowadays we have a picture that bears some resemblance: the Jewish elites in the US colluding with the genocidal government politicians in Israel, at the background of huge wealth disparity in the US society and real genocide happening to Palestinians. Trump's ideas of building his hotels in the Palestinian territory after what remains of Palestinians is forced away certainly does not help, as he is colluding with the genocidal politicians.
Those Jews and Israelites do behave quite like those of the past in Germany, and then worse (in Germany Jews were not responsible of any genocide).
I understand that this is certainly not the only source of the current rise of antisemitism, and that for antisemites in the Western countries this is what they observe from away and not live through themselves.
Still, I suspect this is probably an important factor, even if not the only one.
Thanks for sharing your opinion. However, I want to clarify something.
When I refer to German Jewish elites who became the public face of the revolutionary movement, I’m not claiming they made a mistake, nor that they led the revolution that ended in disaster. I’m describing how many ordinary Germans perceived the situation at the time, including the belief that Jews were rich and largely unaffected by the economic collapse—a belief Hitler stresses in his book Mein Kampf. From my perspective, it isn’t relevant whether influential revolutionaries were Catholic, Protestant, or Jewish. Every individual represents themselves, not the demographic they belong to, even when someone believes they recognize a pattern. Correlation isn’t causation. One thing is safe to say: they were all Germans who wanted a better Germany, but were guided by little sensible strategy.
Hitler didn’t invent that ideology about German Jews. He stepped into beliefs that had been sold to him at some point as a young man, and he resold them more effectively than anyone else at the time. He wasn’t the author of those ideas—his tactics simply made him an exceptionally skilled reseller of the spirit of his time, tactics that might not have worked a decade earlier or later.
In other words, my point is about perception: how large segments of ordinary German society interpreted events when Hitler arrived on the scene. That perception is historically documented.
Combined with centuries-old Christian antisemitism—reinforced by figures like Martin Luther, who campaigned for violence against Jews—it created a perfect storm that had been building long before Hitler exploited it.
I have no idea to what extent Jews were "elites" in pre-Nazi German society. What seems obvious to me is that when a society is failing to satisfy the needs of the large majority, the natural category to attack would be wealthy and powerful people, not some minority that is associated in people's perception with wealthy and powerful people. It also seems obvious to me that Jews have been attacked for being both "too rich" and "too poor" -- Cossacks hardly attacked peasant villages due to the Jews' excessive wealth. So I suspect that wealthy and powerful people divert a common-sense reaction from those who feel excluded to an alternate target, and anti-Semitism has always provided one. And, watching the reaction to the Jewish state's response to 1,200 murders and hundreds of kidnappings, I see the same anti-Semitism in the reaction.
This aligns with my thoughts. Great to know I am not alone.
Thank you, Alan!