The Unholy Truth

The Unholy Truth

Why Christianity’s Biggest Enemy Is Wearing a Cross

The “war on Christianity” isn’t being fought by liberals or atheists — it’s being lost inside the church itself.

Tanner the Humanist's avatar
Tanner the Humanist
Nov 05, 2025
∙ Paid
A cracked church cross and a faded American flag under a darkening sky, symbolizing the internal collapse of modern American Christianity.
The real war on Christianity isn’t fought from outside — it’s the slow fire burning inside its own walls.

There’s a story American Christians love to tell. They’re the last defenders of truth, the moral backbone of a decaying world — the persecuted few standing between God and chaos. The media mocks them, liberals hate them, schools corrupt their kids, and somehow that all proves the world is at war with Christianity.

That’s the myth. The reality is uglier: if Christianity is dying in America, it’s not atheists, gays, Muslims, or Hollywood killing it. Christians are. The so-called “war on Christianity” is friendly fire — a slow, painful collapse fueled by hypocrisy, greed, politics, and a complete misunderstanding of the man they claim to follow.

Now, before anyone reaches for the pitchforks — this isn’t an attack on anyone. It’s an honest look at what’s gone wrong inside the faith itself. So just to be clear: when I say “Christians” or “non-Christians,” I’m not playing the “us versus them” game. As a principle, I always use “they” for every group and “us” for none. This isn’t about sides — and it goes without saying, not every Christian, only the ones who fit the mold this piece is about: the loudest ones who’ve turned their version of faith into the public face of Christianity in America.



The Real Enemy Isn’t Outside the Church

You can’t blame outsiders for what’s happening inside. Church attendance in America is collapsing faster than any point in history. Young people are leaving not because they hate God, but because they hate the noise that pretends to speak for Him. They see preachers protecting predators, televangelists buying jets, and politicians waving Bibles to win votes. If this is what “Christian values” look like, who wouldn’t walk away?

Gallup says belief in organized religion has dropped to record lows. But the same people still say they believe in Jesus. That means faith isn’t dying — churches are. The brand of Christianity people were sold has gone rotten, and believers themselves are the ones spoiling it.


Jesus Wouldn’t Last Five Minutes in Most Churches

If Jesus showed up today, half of American Christians wouldn’t recognize him. He’d be brown, poor, homeless, and preaching love for enemies, not vengeance for elections. He’d be talking about forgiving debts, feeding the hungry, and selling possessions to help the poor. He wouldn’t fit into any megachurch, and Fox News would call him a socialist before he reached the parking lot.

The irony is brutal: the man who said “blessed are the peacemakers” has become the mascot for gun-toting nationalism. The preacher who said “turn the other cheek” is now invoked to justify war, punishment, and cruelty. Jesus didn’t need enemies. Christians made him one.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Unholy Truth to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Tanner the Humanist
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture