The Holy Spirit Wasn’t Always God

Centuries of debate and politics turned a vague “helper” into the third person of the Trinity

Aug 19, 2025

∙ Paid

A digital illustration depicts a dimly lit, dramatic scene inside a grand church council hall. Bishops in ceremonial robes are seated at long wooden tables, arguing and pointing at scrolls and books. Above the center of the room, a glowing white dove, representing the Holy Spirit, hovers. Its form is indistinct, partially blurred and shifting like smoke or a flame. In the background, a large mural is visible. The figures of God the Father and Jesus the Son are clearly and sharply painted, but the space where the Holy Spirit would be depicted is left as an unfinished sketch on bare plaster. The room is lit by flickering torches and moonlight filtering through a large window, emphasizing the tense and uncertain atmosphere. — How the Holy Spirit rose from God’s breath to God Himself — a decision shaped more by politics than scripture.

For many Christians today, the Trinity feels like a given. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit — three persons, one God. But the truth is the Holy Spirit wasn’t always God. The Spirit’s rise from vague biblical presence to full divinity was a long, mes…

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Tanner the Humanist.

Or purchase a paid subscription.

The Unholy Truth

The Holy Spirit Wasn’t Always God

Centuries of debate and politics turned a vague “helper” into the third person of the Trinity

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Tanner the Humanist.